The5ers and For Traders represent a genuine generational gap in the prop firm space, and this comparison is as much about firm maturity as it is about rules. The5ers launched in Israel in 2016 and has spent nearly a decade building toward its current $4,000,000 scaling ceiling, a figure no firm in this comparison batch matches, backed by $43 million-plus in referenced payouts. For Traders launched in 2023 and took a different growth path, opening physical offices across Dubai, Prague, and Kuala Lumpur within a few years and building a customizable challenge structure that gives traders more upfront control over their split percentage than The5ers’ scaling-based progression. Both firms carry strong review signals for their respective sizes — The5ers with roughly 19,000-plus reviews at 4.8/5, For Traders with a smaller but still substantial base near 1,900 reviews at 4.3/5.
The problem: The catch with The5ers’ headline numbers is genuinely worth understanding before you buy a challenge. Independent reviewers have flagged that the advertised “up to 100%” profit split is technically accurate but meaningfully underspecified on the firm’s own marketing pages: traders don’t discover until reading the FAQ that the starting split is actually 50% on some programs, and reaching the full 100% figure requires scaling an account all the way to $1.28 million, a multi-year journey for most funded traders. For Traders has its own transparency gap in the other direction: its 48-hour payment guarantee and customizable split selector are attractive at signup, but its Trustpilot page shows a real pattern of traders reporting account breaches during high-volatility periods, with the firm’s official responses citing execution factors rather than acknowledging any rule-design contribution. Neither issue is disqualifying on its own, but both are the kind of detail easy to miss when comparing headline percentages rather than reading the actual account-stage terms.
Quick Comparison
| The5ers | For Traders | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $39 per $5K High Stakes challenge | $69 per challenge |
| Rating | 4.8 / 5 | 4.3 / 5 |
| Free Trial | No | No |
| Best For | Traders building a long-term funded career who want the largest scaling ceiling and a decade-proven firm | Traders who want to customize their profit-split percentage at signup and value visible multi-office infrastructure |
| Ease of Use | 7 / 10 | 7 / 10 |
| Support Rating | 8 / 10 | 7 / 10 |
| Mobile App | No | No |
| Start The5ers’ Scaling Track → | See For Traders’ Custom Split Options → |
Pros & Cons
- Nearly a decade of continuous operation since 2016, among the longest track records in the retail prop firm industry
- Scaling path reaches $4,000,000 in funded capital, the largest ceiling of any firm in this comparison batch
- Profit split can reach 100% at advanced scaling tiers, though it starts lower depending on the program chosen
- $43 million-plus in independently referenced payouts to traders since inception
- Full profit-split range (50-100%) isn’t clearly surfaced on the homepage; the 100% figure requires scaling an account to $1.28 million, per independent reviewers
- Standard funded-stage split starts at just 80% (or as low as 50% on the Hyper Growth track), well below the headline 100% figure
- No daily withdrawal option; payouts process bi-weekly and only once an account reaches funded status
- Customizable split selector lets traders choose 70%, 80%, or 90% at signup, trading a fee or discount for their preferred rate
- 48-hour payment guarantee: if payout isn’t received in time, the firm pays 100% of the trader’s profit
- Physical offices in Dubai, Prague, and Kuala Lumpur, giving it more visible corporate infrastructure than most peers
- 15% of evaluation-phase profits paid to traders even before they become funded
- Founded in 2023, giving it roughly one-fifth the operating history of The5ers
- Leverage drops from up to 1:125 during evaluation to just 1:40 once an account is funded
- Accounts inactive for 30 consecutive days are automatically closed
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
| Feature | The5ers | For Traders | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Years in Operation | 10 years (since 2016) | 3 years (since 2023) | The5ers |
| Max Scaling Ceiling | $4,000,000 | $300,000 (premium program) | The5ers |
| Trustpilot Review Volume | 19,000+ | ~1,900 | The5ers |
| Starting Funded Split | 50-80% depending on program, scales to 100% | 70-90% selectable at signup | Tie |
| Payment/Payout Guarantee | Bi-weekly cycle, no missed-window penalty disclosed | 48-hour guarantee; 100% of profit paid if missed | For Traders |
| Integrations | MT5, cTrader; 3,000+ tradeable stocks alongside forex, metals, and indices | Purple Trading (Cyprus) and dxFeed (Ireland) as named liquidity providers | — |
Final Verdict
Winner: The5ers
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it actually take to reach The5ers’ 100% profit split?
Reaching the full 100% profit split requires scaling a funded account all the way to a $1.28 million balance, according to propfirmapp.com’s 2026 analysis of The5ers’ published terms. For most funded traders, this represents a multi-year progression rather than something achievable in the first year of funded trading, so the headline 100% figure should be understood as a ceiling, not a starting point.
What is The5ers’ actual starting profit split?
The5ers’ starting split varies significantly by program: as low as 50% on the Hyper Growth evaluation track, up to 75-80% on the High Stakes and Bootcamp programs, according to multiple 2026 independent reviews. Traders should confirm the specific starting split for their chosen program before purchasing, rather than assuming the marketed “up to 100%” figure applies immediately.
Does For Traders let me pick my own profit split?
Yes, this is one of For Traders’ most distinctive features: traders can select 70% (for a discounted challenge price), the standard 80%, or 90% (for an additional fee) at the point of signup. This gives more immediate control than The5ers’ scaling-based progression, which requires hitting performance and balance milestones over time.
Which firm has the longer, more established track record?
The5ers has a clear advantage here, having operated continuously since 2016, roughly seven years longer than For Traders, which launched in 2023. The5ers’ longer history is reflected in its larger Trustpilot review base (19,000+ versus roughly 1,900) and its independently referenced $43 million-plus in total payouts.
Can I trade stocks and indices at both firms?
The5ers offers access to over 3,000 stocks alongside forex, metals, and indices through MT5 and cTrader, giving it notably broader instrument coverage. For Traders’ available instruments are less explicitly documented in independent reviews and should be confirmed directly on the firm’s official site, as its marketing emphasizes commodities, currencies, futures, and indices rather than a large individual stock catalog.